TNR BLOGS

January 08, 2009 | 8:20 PM
January 08, 2009 | 8:00 PM
January 08, 2009 | 6:03 PM

January 07, 2009 | 12:20 PM
January 07, 2009 | 12:13 PM
January 07, 2009 | 9:41 AM

January 08, 2009 | 6:31 PM
January 08, 2009 | 4:13 PM
January 08, 2009 | 2:50 PM

July 26, 2008 | 2:24 PM
July 23, 2008 | 1:55 PM
July 17, 2008 | 3:56 PM

January 08, 2009 | 5:12 PM
January 08, 2009 | 3:25 PM
January 08, 2009 | 1:16 PM
COLUMNISTS
TODAY'S STORIES
09.10.2008
Kinsley on McCain's Temper

If true, this anecdote from Kinsley's Daily Beast column today is pretty chilling. (And the source sounds pretty reliable.):

McCain’s game is craps. So is Jeff Dearth’s. Jeff was at the table when McCain showed up and happily made room for him. Apparently there is some kind of rule or tradition in craps that everyone’s hands are supposed to be above the table when the dice are about to be thrown. McCain—“very likely distracted by one of the many people who approached him that evening,” Jeff says charitably—apparently was violating this rule. A small middle-aged woman at the table, apparently a “regular,” reached out and pulled McCain’s arm away. I’ll let Jeff take over the story:

“McCain immediately turned to the woman and said between clenched teeth: ‘DON’T TOUCH ME.’ The woman started to explain...McCain interrupted her: ‘DON’T TOUCH ME,’ he repeated viciously. The woman again tried to explain. ‘DO YOU KNOW WHO I AM? DO YOU KNOW WHO YOU’RE TALKING TO?’ McCain continued, his voice rising and his hands now raised in the ‘bring it on’ position. He was red-faced. By this time all the action at the table had stopped. I was completely shocked. McCain had totally lost it, and in the space of about ten seconds. ‘Sir, you must be courteous to the other players at the table,’ the pit boss said to McCain. “DO YOU KNOW WHO I AM? ASK ANYBODY AROUND HERE WHO I AM.”

This being Puerto Rico, the pit boss might not have known McCain. But the senator continued in full fury—“DO YOU KNOW WHO YOU’RE TALKING TO? DO YOU KNOW WHO I AM?”—and crisis was avoided only when Jeff offered to change places and stand between McCain and the woman who had touched his arm.

Kinsely goes on to argue that McCain's arrogance here is even more alarming than his temper. I agree, but don't find it as surprising as he does. McCain's arrogance has cropped even in some of the more flattering profiles of him over the years. For example, in an oblique way, Kinsley's piece reminded me this great Arizona Republic piece:

It's 1955 in Annapolis, Md., and Midshipman John McCain and his roommate, Frank Gamboa, are eating lunch at the mess hall at the U.S. Naval Academy. A first classman, a "firstie" in Navy parlance, begins dressing down a Filipino steward.

Gamboa hardly notices this exchange, but young John McCain is paying close attention. Since the steward is an enlisted man, he cannot fight back. The firstie is being a bully, a no-no at the Naval Academy.  OAS_AD('ArticleFlex_1')

The man outranks everyone at the table. McCain and Gamboa are barely past being plebes, the school's lowest rank. Fearing trouble, other underclassmen eat quickly and leave. The browbeating continues.

Finally, McCain can take no more.

"Hey, why don't you pick on someone your own size?" McCain blurts out.

There is a moment of silent shock at the table.

"What did you say?" replies the firstie.

"Why don't you stop picking on him?" McCain says. "He's doing the best he can."

"What is your name, mister?" snaps the firstie, an open threat to put McCain on report.

"Midshipman John McCain the Third," McCain says, looking straight at the upperclassman. "What's yours?"

The firstie saw the look in McCain's eyes. And fled.

Unquestionably a brave and noble deed. But even here you sense McCain is pulling rank--saying some form of, "Do you know who I am?"

--Noam Scheiber

Posted: Thursday, October 09, 2008 4:22 PM with 16 comment(s)

Comments

You must be logged-in to comment.

Not a subscriber? Click here to get a digital or print and digital subscription to The New Republic!

simon greenwood said:

McCain has done enough mean, vindictive things on the record that I don't really see the need for anecdotes like Dearth's.  This one sounds a little more reliable than the anonymous journalists watching McCain chew out his wife, at least, but there still isn't any public record of it.

October 9, 2008 4:38 PM

MichLib said:

You're stretching it a little far there, Noam. The anecdote about sticking up for the little guy doesn't come off at all like a temper problem. If your goal in this post is to make McCain look bad, you've failed. That story makes McCain sound like McCain wants to sound like - a fair, honorable man who sticks up for the little guy. Admittedly, his policies and his campaign show nothing of that nature, but as we all should know even anecdotes from 50 years ago like this one tend to work.

October 9, 2008 4:43 PM

aharris61 said:

I am very hesitant to credit this report as truthful.  I am no McCain fan (GO OBAMA!!!), but I have serious qualms about this.  In particular, the hostile question, "Do you know who I am?", is the same which has been attributed to McCain in an extremely unflattering report of McCain on vacation which has been posted online.  That other online report is uncorroborated by the purported witness/author.  I do not wish to traffic in unsubstantiated reports, so suffice to say that the other online report characterizes McCain as an arrogant, sexist, racist beast.  I found that report wholly unconvincing, and the fact that this report attributes to McCain the same hostile question gives me pause as to its authenticity as well.  (If either or, God-forbid, both of these reports are truthful, McCain may well be a far greater danger than Bush).

October 9, 2008 4:44 PM

icarusr said:

He's a mean, nasty old bugger.  What's the news, again?

October 9, 2008 4:45 PM

satyendra said:

MichLib, as a student he announces that he's John McCain the III.  McCain's grandfather was well known in the navy, so yes,  the subtext is, don't you dare mess with me.  True that this time he threw around his name to stick up for a little guy.

Aharris61, agreed that "Do you know who I am" could be some sort of repetition of an urban legend. Or, it could be McCain's stock line when he's not catered to.

Icarus, your statement on another thread that McCain probably drank 1/2 Maker's Mark and broke Cindy's porcelain Russian doll collection after losing the debate was priceless.

October 9, 2008 5:15 PM

Noam Scheiber said:

MichLib - the point of the anecdote i quoted isn't to show he has a temper problem. it's to show that his reflex is to pull rank, which he was doing by alluding to his famous father and grandfather.

October 9, 2008 5:15 PM

ndmackenzie said:

Tim Dickinson's Rolling Stone article on the "make-believe maverick" is must reading for anyone seeking to understand John McCain.

www.rollingstone.com/.../make_believe_maverick_the_real_john_mccain

October 9, 2008 5:18 PM

porkido said:

Noam should have reminded us that by declaring his name, McCain made it clear that he was of naval royalty (the son AND grandson of 4-star admirals), and should not be f'd with...that would clarify the arrogance of his actions and words in this incident.

October 9, 2008 5:26 PM

phargle said:

In the story, McCain stuck up for the little guy long before his name came into question, and only gave his name when asked.  Please, let's not get so far gone that we're willing to malign McCain for doing something right.

The main "DO YOU KNOW WHO I AM?" story sounds like a fake.

October 9, 2008 6:47 PM

JEFF FREY said:

Sometimes, like in this Annapolis anecdote, pulling rank can actually be a good thing. I wouldn't criticize him at all for that incident, if he did to to help out someone who was being unfairly targeted, rather than doing it to help himself.

October 9, 2008 7:00 PM

singlespeed said:

The issue isn't that McCain pulled rank "after" the steward asked him who he was. It's the fact that, despite having NO rank, McCain pulled Papa's rank out. Considering that McCain has used his paternal name to gain what he otherwise cannot achieve of his own accord. McCain has consistently used cronyism to achieve his goals in life and "Do you know who I am?" is one of his trademarks.

October 9, 2008 7:24 PM

ndmackenzie said:

phargle, JEF REY -

The Rolling Stone article I mentioned earlier makes it clear that the incidents Noam Scheiber refers to are by no means unusual - indeed they appear to represent the modus operandi for John McCain.

October 9, 2008 8:07 PM

JEFF FREY said:

I understand. But I still think that even pulling papa's rank to protect a browbeaten steward from a bully is not something to complain about (assuming that the anecdote is true, of course). In the anecdote, it was the only thing that he could have done to stop something that shouldn't have been happening in the first place. Pulling papa's rank to advance yourself is another thing. And the craps table story, if true, is certainly damning. Not that we need more information to prove that McCain has a serious temper and judgement problem.

October 9, 2008 9:34 PM

Political Animal said:

Temper, Temper Here's a story about John McCain's temper (h/t): "McCain's game is craps. So is Jeff Dearth's. Jeff was at the table when McCain showed up and happily made room for him. Apparently there is some kind of rule...

October 10, 2008 12:57 AM

sdemuth said:

The first story, if true, is a relevant and devastating indictment of John McCain's character.  The Annapolis story isn't particular relevant, and if true, is largely complementary of his character.

I say the Annapolis story is irrelevant because it is about a 19 year old male in the hypermasculine environment of a service academy.   There aren't many people who could get into the Naval Academy who wouldn't strut their stuff - including papa's rank - in a confrontation.  And the confrontation described here serves to paint McCain's basic sense of fairness in a flattering light.  I'd be damned pleased to be able to have this story told about me at age 19,  when I was using what little "muscle" I had the courage to summon for far less noble things than standing up for a minority in a powerless position being attacked by a bully.

October 10, 2008 8:35 AM

tembrach said:

I liked that story about John in the Naval Academy. It points out that McCain has a real decent streak in him. And it does not bother me that  he has occasional flashes of anger. So did Clinton and Kennedy. What bothers me is that McCain is fairly clueless about the economy; and the economy is the critical issue of the day for our nation.

I like McCain. He is my favorite Republican. If he were elected 8 years ago, instead of Bush, the country would be in a better place.  But I am afraid he is inadequate to addressing our current crisis

October 10, 2008 10:31 AM