TNR BLOGS

September 06, 2008 | 4:31 PM
September 06, 2008 | 3:43 PM
September 05, 2008 | 8:32 PM

September 05, 2008 | 2:53 PM
September 05, 2008 | 3:45 AM
September 05, 2008 | 12:25 AM

September 06, 2008 | 3:14 PM
September 06, 2008 | 3:10 PM
September 05, 2008 | 4:28 PM

July 26, 2008 | 2:24 PM
July 23, 2008 | 1:55 PM
July 17, 2008 | 3:56 PM

September 05, 2008 | 1:35 PM
September 03, 2008 | 1:01 PM
September 02, 2008 | 6:20 PM
COLUMNISTS
TODAY'S STORIES
10.03.2008
Tina Does Hillary

Hillary gets the Tina Brown treatment in Newsweek. It's an entertaining read for several reasons--maybe none more so than Brown's horror at encountering, for the first time apparently, the sheer drudgery of reporting on a campaign; in Brown's words, "It's like being trapped in a moving bathysphere." (And how many writers has she sent to live in that bathysphere over the years?)

But the point of Brown's article, so far as I can tell, is to paint Hillary as the champion of the "Invisible Woman":

It's a revolt that has been overdue for a while and has now found its focus in Clinton's candidacy. In 1952, Ralph Ellison's revelatory novel, "Invisible Man," nailed the experience of being black in America. In the relentless youth culture of the early 21st century, if you are 50 and female, the novel that's being written on your forehead every day is "Invisible Woman." All over the country there are vigorous, independent, self-liberated boomer women—women who possess all the management skills that come from raising families while holding down demanding jobs, women who have experience, enterprise and, among the empty nesters, a little financial independence, yet still find themselves steadfastly dissed and ignored. Advertisers don't want them. TV networks dump their older anchorwomen off the air. Hollywood studios refuse to write parts for them. Employers make it clear they'd prefer a "fresh (cheaper) face."

I'm not sure if the plight of the suburban empty-nester who can't find stylish clothes for herself at the mall is akin to the plight of a black man living under Jim Crow, but that's evidently Brown's thesis--and she's sticking to it:

It was hard not to be caught up in the euphoria at the Columbus Athenaeum when her primary results started to come in. I found myself jammed between two exultant Columbus ladies, a high-fiving yoga-studio owner in her 50s and a human resources director of a software company roughly the same age. They were raising the roof along with the band to the old 1965 McCoys hit "Hang on Sloopy."

For all the invisible women, it's the only anthem they've got. And for their sake alone, Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton should not give up the fight.

And Hillary should stay in the race for Brown, too. After all, as her author's bio notes, Brown's currently working on a book about the Clintons. I don't think that book becomes a best seller if Hillary's the junior senator from New York when it comes out.

--Jason Zengerle 

Posted: Monday, March 10, 2008 10:48 AM with 15 comment(s)

Comments

You must be logged-in to comment.

Not a subscriber? Click here to get a digital or print and digital subscription to The New Republic!

teplukhin2you said:

Rather peculiar headline, that. Got blackton's interest, for sure, but perplexing nonetheless

March 10, 2008 11:19 AM

boneill said:

Ugh.  "Hang on Sloopy" is one of my favorite songs, and it contains the single best lyric in the history of rock and roll.  This makes me sad.

March 10, 2008 11:21 AM

teplukhin2you said:

This Tina Brown piece practically screams out for Wonkette to demolish it. IIRC Cox now writes for Newsweek's rival. Go get 'em, girl

March 10, 2008 11:22 AM

drdannyu said:

bone, which lyric is that?  (I am, for once, serious.)

And, by "shear drudgery," I assume that Tina has been covering the Clinton coiffure beat?

March 10, 2008 11:40 AM

shislandguy said:

There is absolutely no comparison (well, none worth making) between the black experience of Ellison's Invisible Man, and the "self-liberated boomer women" HRH sees (depends on?) today. To say that this, only confirms my opinion of Tatler Brown

March 10, 2008 11:44 AM

jeidel1906 said:

Hang on Sloopy is a song frequently played at Ohio State sporting events.  Probably has more to do with the fact that that song is ubiquitous in Ohio than the need for a theme song for female baby boomer politicians.

March 10, 2008 11:49 AM

virginiacentrist said:

Hillary's story is the ultimate story of women's empowerment. Let's ignore the fact that she sacrificed her self-respect and legitimized humiliation of women in order to gain power.

Every night, before they go to bed, I want my daughters to know that the best way to acheive your dreams is to marry a powerful man and to wait for him to humiliate you so you can use the sympathy to catipult yourself to success. That's the american dream, in a nutshell.

March 10, 2008 11:55 AM

Rhubarbs said:

"Hang on Sloopy" < "Sloop John B"

But I actually give Hillary some credit for tapping into middle-class women's desire to be heard and to have a seat at the table. For nearly two generations, women have been taking the managerial lead in American life, continuing to run family households even while integrating (almost) fully into the workplace. On average, women are now better educated than men, too. But we still see the same tired old parade of (white) men vying for the top jobs in politics, big business, most of the professions, and even large swaths of academia.

I don't give the women who back Hillary for this reason much credit, however, since backing Hillary as the feminist we've-earned-it candidate makes about as much sense as backing Phyllis Schlafly. Hillary traded on her husband's fame and connections to step over three other women who had earned their way to the top of New York politics. In terms of the patriarchal and class power dynamics that exclude women from political leadership, Hillary Clinton is a "male" candidate. It's kind of sad to see people embracing the candidate of the entrenched, moneyed old-boy's club as the beacon of feminist achievement, especially since there are (finally!) an adequate number of women at the top of state and national politics to compete for the presidency. Why Hillary and not Sibelius or Napolitano or Murray or Cantwell?

March 10, 2008 12:04 PM

fougasseu said:

Bill Does Limbaugh.

Bill called in while in Texas, and you can hear it online (the easiest way is via Andrew Sullivan). He's sounding more like Haley Barbour every day.

In the early '60s someone wrote in "The Nation"  that the American Negro is now entering the "consciousness of the forum", thanks to the writings of Ellison, Baldwin, and Richard Wright.

Obama is not a fluke. He's the fruition of a tremendous amount of suffering, and growth.

Listening to Hillary in Mississippi with her latest weird frog-in-the-pot speech pattern, listening to Bill stir up those poor and poorly educated white voters in Ohio and Texas that Lee Atwater always counted on - beyond ugly.

March 10, 2008 12:11 PM

boneill said:

Rhubarbs- SloopJohn B is a great, great song, but I do love "Hang on Sloopy."  To me it just smacks of this kind of unbridled freedom, of getting out of despair.

The lyric, drdan, is after the breakdown, where the singer crrons "Sloopy let your hair down girl, let it hang down on me."  The first part is the metaphorical "relax, baby- it is going to be all right.  We're here together, and it don't matter what your daddy do or where you are from or what anyone says- your worries are over, and it is just me and you."  And then the second part brings in the physical, with her long har draping onto her lover, whether they are actually making love or just holding on to each other.  It is that subtle shift from the metaphorical to the physical, with its simple yet evocative imagry, that blows my mind.  And then he sings it again, louder, and then the song really picks up, and it explodes.  I love it.

Yes- I've thought about "Hang on Sloopy" way too much.

March 10, 2008 12:32 PM

Crock1701 said:

Here's the reason for "Hang on Sloopy" in Ohio:

www.ohiohistorycentral.org/entry.php

The resolution's something of a hoot.  Also, I must say wtf-ness at comparing the plight of the 50 year old boomer woman with a black man under Jim Crow.  That ranks right up there with Steinem's pre-NH Times Op-ed about how women got the vote 60 years after black people in sheer audacity.

March 10, 2008 12:44 PM

jblumenfeld said:

What a surprise, that Tina Brown does a story on the election and finds out that the real, secret, underlying story is about... Tina Brown!  I am shocked. Shocked.

March 10, 2008 12:55 PM

teplukhin2you said:

what jeidel said. Hang on Sloopy's the saddest pop song I know. Indelibly associated with every one of OSU's Rose Bowl-denying last-minute victories over Michigan.

March 10, 2008 1:58 PM

CharlesFosterKane said:

"Steinem's pre-NH Times Op-ed about how women got the vote 60 years after black people in sheer audacity."

She wasn't the only one. A number of Clinton surrogates were making that spurious argument. Oh, those poor rich white women whose grandmothers couldn't vote when black people could -- well, could in theory -- well, were being lynched for not toeing the line, but what the hell. Disgusting.

March 10, 2008 2:30 PM

ChanRobt said:

I don't like Hillary for very much.  But, putting the press in a mens room right up against the urinals!  Well, I've got to at least consider voting for her on that score.

March 11, 2008 2:16 PM