TNR BLOGS

May 15, 2008 | 8:03 PM
May 15, 2008 | 6:26 PM
May 15, 2008 | 4:42 PM

May 15, 2008 | 8:41 PM
May 15, 2008 | 7:06 PM
May 15, 2008 | 6:35 PM

May 05, 2008 | 1:35 PM
May 02, 2008 | 5:26 PM
May 02, 2008 | 2:40 PM
COLUMNISTS
TODAY'S STORIES
19.11.2007
Time for a New Know-Nothing Party

So at lunch time I ran out to get my car's emissions checked. (Twas a strikingly painless process that took all of 5 minutes, if you can believe that. Go MD MVA!)  On the way, I passed this United Methodist church with a sign out front boldly proclaiming:

Experts built the Titanic.

Amateurs Built the Ark. 

Whatever your thoughts on biblical literalism, this is a tiresome sign of the times and, specifically, this culture's widespread antipathy toward expertise--an antipathy that a certain breed of bash-the-establishment politician has long promoted, and which the current administration has done everything it can to fuel. (For details of the Bushies' war on expertise, see Editor Foer's "The Closing of the Presidential Mind" from July 2004; sorry, can't find a link). 

I just don' t get it. Sure, sure, we all like to mouth off about how we're so much smarter and competent and honest than all those clowns who run the government/the news media/the Yankees--you name it. (It is the rare American who hasn't at some point sworn: I could do a better job than him/her with my eyes closed.) Often, this knee-jerk scorn is directed at pointy-headed professionals like economists or foreign policy wonks or at highly public fields like politics, journalism or entertainment. But ship builders? When did our overabundance of attitude morph into some bizarre conviction that anyone with a specialized base of knowledge is automatically a buffoon and not to be trusted? 

I just hope the church's minister remembers his love of amateurs the next time he needs a root canal.   

--Michelle Cottle

Posted: Monday, November 19, 2007 7:17 PM with 15 comment(s)

Comments

You must be logged-in to comment.

Not a subscriber? Click here to get a digital or print and digital subscription to The New Republic!

epackard-02 said:

You know those darn Methodists. They have an overriding conviction to deprofessionalize the world.

November 19, 2007 3:24 PM

boneill said:

But- didn't God design the arc, right down to the cubit?   If you are a believer, that is a pretty damn good designer.  All Noah had to do was follow the divine blueprints, and, whammy- he has an arc.  So it isn't really amatuer.  

And, frankly, the good Lord left the building of the Titanic to the Irish.  Professional, my foot.  

November 19, 2007 3:34 PM

Ivanova said:

Boneill beat me to it -- God is an amateur? Someone didn't think this through very carefully. Plus, what the heck is the point? Even if you agreed with the anti-elitist sentiment (which I don't), it's not a theological or religious statement. It'd be like the church bulletin board telling you it was time to mulch round your daffodils, or whatever; hardly relevant even if true.

November 19, 2007 4:08 PM

purcellneil said:

boneill,

Next you'll blame the Irish for making that iceberg as well, I suppose!

Neil

November 19, 2007 4:36 PM

adamvaught said:

Oh, I get it. It's because the Titanic sank. Clever.

However, if I remember correctly the Titanic sank because it ran into an iceburg. But didn't Noah run the Ark into a freaking mountain? It's hard to sink when you run into, you know, land.

November 19, 2007 5:09 PM

boneill said:

And, really, didn't god make the iceberg?  So isn't it a little snippy to get yucks out of it?  

Also, god would have wanted the arc to stay afloat.  It was his plan to kill everyone but one family.  He sure had it in for the Astor's, though, and the poor.  

November 19, 2007 5:22 PM

tnmats said:

The good minister better hope unskilled morons designed his sanctuary.  If actual structural engineers and professional architects designed it, then it should have collapsed by now, right?

I really get tired of that attitude.  When I hear people gripe about how this product isn't built right, or

they could do a better job, I retort "THEN DO IT!"  I then blast them back that they NEVER had to

actually bring a single product from design to final production (I've done it dozens of times in

my career).  It takes someone who's actually done it to know the multitude of trade-offs involved.

Then again these comments are typically from idiots can can't make change at the cash register without

a flippin' calculator.

November 19, 2007 5:27 PM

boneill said:

I'm an amatuer, and the boat I built didn't work out well.

It didn't work out well, at all.

November 19, 2007 5:29 PM

epackard-02 said:

Some of you are hilarious. Getting so wound up over a whimsical religous bumper sticker.  

Touchy touchy.

November 19, 2007 7:54 PM

boneill said:

epack, it is more just my irritation with the whole anti-intellectual thread- not just anti-professional, though the two overlap- idea in this country.  I don't consider myself an intellectual or anything, and I have zero marketable skills, so I don't really have too much of a dog in this fight.  But I despise the trend of saying that if you don't like NASCAR and believe in science and use your critical thinking faculties to work out problems you aren't a "real American".   Plus I like taking things to their logical conclusion, which is what we are doing with this sign.   Helps to point out the absurdities.

Also, I like making jackass jokes.

November 19, 2007 9:57 PM

nancyirving said:

Still, it sank.

November 20, 2007 1:33 AM

blackton said:

I am not too sure that God is all that professional either, here you had a guy (or gal) who made a bunch of angels a bunch of whom rebelled. Then he make the earth and two of every creature but one man and shocked by what the man starting doing to himself and the docile animals decided to carve a woman out of him from a spare rib, at which point the man started to have sex with his own appendage. His former rib, now woman then makes a muck up of things by eating from a tree that God said don't eat. Why God chose to put the tree in the centre of eden, and let the serpent run around, and put shiny fruit on it (instead of asparagus) was also amatuer hour. Then he kicks them out of eden, creating generations of incestuous dolts who behaved as such and then he decided to drown them all, creating another series of generations of incestuous dolts.

We are only up to the ark and his track record is pretty bad. I will take the designers of the Titanic and just hire another driver, one whom, you know, doesn't run into a freaking iceberg.

November 20, 2007 10:50 AM

dhauck said:

blackton -

1. Don't blame God - it's all the unfortunate results of just one week of work; anybody can have a bad week.

2. Like you've never had sex with your own appendage...

November 20, 2007 12:58 PM

boneill said:

Ding ding ding!

Dhauck wins!

November 20, 2007 1:08 PM

blackton said:

dhauk, I laughed so hard the person in the next office heard me.

November 20, 2007 1:43 PM